Image 1 of 4
Image 2 of 4
Image 3 of 4
Image 4 of 4
CLP Vacatur Litigation Toolkit | Version 1.0 • June 2026
This toolkit was created for immigration attorneys handling cases affected by the now-vacated Circumvention of Lawful Pathways (“CLP”) Rule.
The CLP issue itself is usually straightforward. The harder question is procedural: determining the correct vehicle based on where the case currently sits. A pending BIA appeal requires a different filing than a final BIA decision. A final IJ order with no appeal requires a different approach altogether.
This toolkit provides filing-ready templates covering the most common procedural postures arising after the June 3, 2026 final judgment in East Bay Sanctuary Covenant v. Trump.
What’s Included
Template 1
Pending BIA Appeal – CLP Sole Basis for Asylum Denial
For cases where:
Appeal remains pending before the BIA
Withholding was granted
Asylum was denied solely because of CLP
Includes:
Notice of Supplemental Authority
Motion to Remand
June 3, 2026 Final Judgment updates
Third-country removal stay language
Template 2
Final BIA Decision – Motion to Reopen
For cases where:
BIA already issued a final decision
Withholding and/or CAT was granted
CLP was the sole or primary obstacle to asylum
Includes:
Motion to Reopen
Direct asylum grant arguments
Alternative limited-remand request
Fifth Circuit vacatur analysis
Third-country removal stay language
Template 3
Pending BIA Appeal – CLP Was Part of the Denial
For cases where:
Appeal remains pending before the BIA
CLP was part of the legal framework
CLP was not necessarily the sole reason relief was denied
Includes:
Notice of Supplemental Authority
Motion to Remand
Contamination/remand framework
Fifth Circuit adaptation language
Third-country removal stay language
Template 4
Final IJ Order – No BIA Appeal Filed
For cases where:
No appeal was filed
IJ granted withholding
Asylum was denied solely because of CLP
Includes:
Immigration Court Motion to Reopen
Limited reopening framework
Family unity arguments
Third-country removal stay language
I created these templates after litigating multiple CLP cases in different procedural postures. The motions are not generic forms. They are built around the procedural issues that repeatedly came up in my own cases after the East Bay litigation and the June 3, 2026 final judgment.
This toolkit was created for immigration attorneys handling cases affected by the now-vacated Circumvention of Lawful Pathways (“CLP”) Rule.
The CLP issue itself is usually straightforward. The harder question is procedural: determining the correct vehicle based on where the case currently sits. A pending BIA appeal requires a different filing than a final BIA decision. A final IJ order with no appeal requires a different approach altogether.
This toolkit provides filing-ready templates covering the most common procedural postures arising after the June 3, 2026 final judgment in East Bay Sanctuary Covenant v. Trump.
What’s Included
Template 1
Pending BIA Appeal – CLP Sole Basis for Asylum Denial
For cases where:
Appeal remains pending before the BIA
Withholding was granted
Asylum was denied solely because of CLP
Includes:
Notice of Supplemental Authority
Motion to Remand
June 3, 2026 Final Judgment updates
Third-country removal stay language
Template 2
Final BIA Decision – Motion to Reopen
For cases where:
BIA already issued a final decision
Withholding and/or CAT was granted
CLP was the sole or primary obstacle to asylum
Includes:
Motion to Reopen
Direct asylum grant arguments
Alternative limited-remand request
Fifth Circuit vacatur analysis
Third-country removal stay language
Template 3
Pending BIA Appeal – CLP Was Part of the Denial
For cases where:
Appeal remains pending before the BIA
CLP was part of the legal framework
CLP was not necessarily the sole reason relief was denied
Includes:
Notice of Supplemental Authority
Motion to Remand
Contamination/remand framework
Fifth Circuit adaptation language
Third-country removal stay language
Template 4
Final IJ Order – No BIA Appeal Filed
For cases where:
No appeal was filed
IJ granted withholding
Asylum was denied solely because of CLP
Includes:
Immigration Court Motion to Reopen
Limited reopening framework
Family unity arguments
Third-country removal stay language
I created these templates after litigating multiple CLP cases in different procedural postures. The motions are not generic forms. They are built around the procedural issues that repeatedly came up in my own cases after the East Bay litigation and the June 3, 2026 final judgment.