Yara Immigration Law Library · National CLP Research Project
CLP Vacatur Remedy Project
Tracking what happens after vacatur.
The CLP Rule was vacated. What happened next is what we are tracking.
Yara Immigration Law Library is collecting Immigration Court and BIA decisions in cases affected by the Circumvention of Lawful Pathways Rule. The goal is to see what actually happens after a CLP-related motion is filed, across courts, circuits and procedural postures.
Submitting takes about two minutes. We want every ruling and every next step, including pending matters and unusual procedural outcomes.
Live snapshot
Last updated: —
- —
- Cases submitted
- —
- Cases coded
- —
- Courts represented
- —
- Circuits represented
- —
- Motions ruled on
- —
- Cases reaching a CLP-free asylum decision
These figures reflect voluntarily submitted cases, including an initial seed cohort from the project’s own practice. They are not a complete or nationally representative sample of CLP-affected cases. A case is counted as reaching a CLP-free asylum decision once the IJ or BIA adjudicates asylum without applying CLP, regardless of the ultimate asylum disposition.
What happened after the motion was filed
Each case is followed from the CLP-related filing forward. We track the ruling, what followed it, and whether the case ultimately reached an asylum adjudication without CLP.
-
Stage 1
Ruling on the CLP filing
How did the adjudicator rule on the CLP-related filing?
-
Stage 2
What happened next
What followed the ruling? One case can count in several rows.
-
Stage 3
CLP-free adjudication status
Has the case reached an asylum decision made without applying CLP?
A ruling on the motion and an asylum adjudication are separate events. Reopening or remand begins a new procedural stage; it does not necessarily complete the post-vacatur process. Stage 3 records whether the case has reached an asylum adjudication without CLP, regardless of the ultimate asylum disposition. Figures are counts of coded cases. Counts under 5 appear as "fewer than 5," and a second small count may also be withheld so the first cannot be worked out.
The Process Beyond the Ruling
A docket entry does not show the full effect of the remedial process. Alongside the legal path, the project tracks a limited set of consequences documented while a CLP-affected case moves through post-vacatur proceedings, and how long each stage takes.
These record what occurred during the process, not conclusions about what caused it. The project does not collect asylum histories, declarations or medical records, and nothing in this section identifies an individual.
Procedural consequences
Derived by Yara from the decision and docket. Number of cases in which each was documented.
Human consequences
May need the submitting attorney's input. Number of cases in which each was documented.
Shown as national totals only, never by court, judge or circuit.
Counts appear once 20 cases are coded.
A count is the number of cases in which a consequence was documented in the decision, the docket or the attorney's submission. It is not a measure of how often the consequence occurred: when the materials are silent, the case is recorded as "not documented," never as "did not occur."
How long each stage took
Completed and still-open cases are reported separately. A case that is still open is never counted as if its current wait were its final duration.
Behind the Numbers
Short, de-identified examples, published only with the submitting attorney's separate permission.
Where the case stood when the motion was filed
The starting point shapes the path. Each coded case is placed by its procedural posture and custody status on the filing date.
Procedural posture
One category per case.
Custody status
One category per case.
What we are seeing
These observations update as the dataset grows. They describe what the submitted decisions show, not what the law requires.
What we are tracking
A ruling is only one point on the path. The project also tracks the procedural questions that shape what happens after a CLP-related filing.
- Reopening vs. reconsideration
- Equitable tolling
- Scope after reopening
- Preserving prior findings
- Asylum discretion
- Security checks
- DHS opposition, silence or joinder
- Release and transfer
- BIA remand
- DHS appeals
- Removed respondents
- Physical presence
- Participation from abroad
- Nunc pro tunc relief
- Facilitation of return
- Third-country removal
Submit a CLP decision
You send the decision and a few procedural facts. We do the coding.
It takes about two minutes. There is no long survey, and you don't need to analyze the decision for us.
What the form asks
- Your name and email
- What you're uploading (IJ decision, motion ruling, reopening or reconsideration order, BIA decision or remand order)
- The respondent's current status and the case's current posture
- DHS's position, if known
- Optional: consequences during the process, with "none of the above occurred, to my knowledge" and "I do not know / prefer not to answer" as choices
- Optional: one or two sentences on anything unusual
- Whether the document is already redacted
- How we may use the submission, one permission at a time
Upload only the decision
Please do not send the Record of Proceedings, privileged communications, medical records, client declarations or supporting exhibits unless we specifically ask for them.
If it isn't redacted
An unredacted decision is never made public or placed in a shared research folder. The original stays restricted, and a person checks every redaction on the separate research copy before anything is shared or quoted.
Permissions are separate
You can contribute to the statistics without agreeing to quotation, sharing, contact or Behind the Numbers. Each is its own choice.
What you're uploading, where the case stands, DHS's position and your permissions.
The secure upload opens as soon as you submit the questions. Files go to a restricted folder.
Every submission requires the attorney to confirm they have the client's informed consent, or are otherwise authorized, to submit the material at the permission level selected. Submitting does not create an attorney-client relationship with Yara Immigration Law Library.
What happens after you submit
- 1You upload the decision.
No long survey. - 2We review and code it.
The legal and procedural details come from the order itself. - 3It joins the national dataset.
Names and A-numbers are never part of the public data. - 4Results appear here, in aggregate.
Numbers are shown in a way designed not to identify any respondent.
How the data works
Methodology
The project adapts the comparative empirical method from the project lead's doctoral research: legal decisions are broken into defined elements, coded the same way every time, and compared across courts and circuits to find patterns that reading decisions one by one would miss. The unit of analysis is one CLP-related motion and everything that followed it. This is not an outcome counter.
Each case is coded in three layers.
- Legal coding. Facts taken from the decisions themselves, not from the submitting attorney's reading: court, circuit, custody status and posture on the filing date; the vehicle filed; how the adjudicator treated the filing; how timeliness and tolling were treated; the DHS position; the dates; and the ruling. Findings already made in the original decision are also coded, privately, as analytical controls. They are never published.
- Remedial pathway. The steps after the ruling, in order: reopening or remand, briefing, security checks, hearings, transfer, appeals by either side, removal, participation from abroad, return, and whether the case reached an asylum adjudication without CLP. The ruling on the motion and the asylum adjudication stay separate throughout.
- Human consequence. A short, fixed list of what occurred during the process, such as continued detention, transfer, removal before completion or continued family separation. Each is recorded as documented or not documented, with its source, and never as a cause.
The analysis starts with counts and the time between steps. Completed and still-open cases are always reported separately, so an open case's current wait is never treated as its final duration. Once the dataset is large enough, categorical clustering and time-to-event analysis show which characteristics travel together along each path. Judges are not ranked, and nothing is scored as a win or a loss.
The first cases come from the project's own practice (the seed cohort). Outside submissions are added as they arrive.
Confidentiality
- The public page shows aggregate numbers only. Counts under 5 appear as "fewer than 5."
- Family separation and health information are reported only as national totals, never by court, judge or circuit.
- Submitted decisions are never published automatically, and respondent names and A-numbers are not part of the dataset.
- Originals stay in a restricted folder. Redacted research copies are checked by a person before any use.
- Please send sensitive materials only if we ask for them.
- Examples in Behind the Numbers require the attorney's separate permission and use approximate periods, not exact dates.
Limits of the data
- Participation is voluntary, so the cases are not a complete or nationally representative sample.
- The dataset begins with a seed cohort from the project's own practice.
- A consequence counted as documented means the materials record it. When the materials are silent, it is recorded as not documented, never as "did not occur."
- Submitting a decision does not create an attorney-client relationship with Yara Immigration Law Library.
Help us build the record of what happened after vacatur.
If you have a CLP-affected case, send us the decision, whatever the ruling and wherever the case went next. The more complete the dataset, the better we can tell which differences come from the law and the record, and which may come from the remedial process itself.
Have several decisions? Email sahar@yaramigrationlaw.com about a batch submission.