Image 2 of 9
Image 3 of 9
Image 4 of 9
Image 5 of 9
Image 6 of 9
Image 7 of 9
Image 8 of 9
Image 9 of 9
Blank Space: Teaching Case| When DHS Appeals a win
The appeal: DHS appeal of a withholding grant.
Mental model: Read what the other side never challenged.
You’ll learn:
✓ Chart the findings that carry a judgment against the challenges actually made.
✓ Concede strategically and align your brief with the decision under review.
✓ Hold an appellant to clear error, finding by finding.
You’ll benefit most if your appeal involves:
• Defending a grant against a government appeal.
• A partial or divided credibility finding.
• An opponent’s brief that is loud about one issue and silent on the dispositive ones.
• An independent documentary holding the appeal never reaches.
What’s inside:
✓ Teaching Case (the full reconstruction)
✓ Annotated Filed Briefs
✓ Editorial Decisions
✓ Lessons from the case
✓ One-page Cheat Sheet
✓ Teaching Deck
The appeal: DHS appeal of a withholding grant.
Mental model: Read what the other side never challenged.
You’ll learn:
✓ Chart the findings that carry a judgment against the challenges actually made.
✓ Concede strategically and align your brief with the decision under review.
✓ Hold an appellant to clear error, finding by finding.
You’ll benefit most if your appeal involves:
• Defending a grant against a government appeal.
• A partial or divided credibility finding.
• An opponent’s brief that is loud about one issue and silent on the dispositive ones.
• An independent documentary holding the appeal never reaches.
What’s inside:
✓ Teaching Case (the full reconstruction)
✓ Annotated Filed Briefs
✓ Editorial Decisions
✓ Lessons from the case
✓ One-page Cheat Sheet
✓ Teaching Deck